Step 1: Check the Set and Era
Not all “old” Pokémon cards are created equal. If you’ve got cards from the **1999–2000 Base Set**, Jungle, Fossil, or Team Rocket—those are the ones people actually care about.
Look for cards with the classic blue backs and “Wizards of the Coast” printed at the bottom. If your cards say Sword & Shield, Scarlet & Violet, or are stamped with anything post-2017, they’re modern and likely have very different value rules.
Step 2: Look for First Edition or Shadowless
Flip the card over and look at the left side of the artwork box. If there’s a little black “1” with “Edition” stamped on it, you’ve got a **First Edition**. These were the first prints ever released—and collectors love them.
Also check for “shadowless” versions. These lack the drop shadow on the right side of the artwork box. Shadowless cards are from early print runs and are rarer than the unlimited versions that came later. A First Edition Shadowless card? That’s cardboard royalty.
Step 3: Holographic or Nah?
If the card sparkles when you tilt it, congrats—it’s a holo (holographic). The OG Base Set holos are still sought after, especially:
– Charizard
– Blastoise
– Venusaur
– Mewtwo
– Raichu (We’ve got one coming live soon!)
– Gyarados
– Hitmonchan (Here’s ours: Hitmonchan Holo – Base Set 7/102)
If it’s a holo AND First Edition or Shadowless, it might be worth grading—even in worn condition. About a year ago I sold an SGC 3 Shadowless Blastoise for $120.
Step 4: Check the Rarity Symbol
Look in the bottom right corner of the card (under the art box). You’ll see one of these:
– ● Circle = Common
– ◆ Diamond = Uncommon
– ★ Star = Rare
This is true for vintage and most modern cards. Stars are generally what you want, but not all rares are valuable. A rare Trainer card? Probably trash. A rare holo Charizard? Now we’re talking.
Step 5: Condition Makes or Breaks Value
Let’s say you have a Base Set Charizard. In PSA 10 condition, that’s a $10,000+ card. In “I-kept-this-in-my-pocket-in-5th-grade” condition? Maybe $50.
Key things to check:
– Corners: Are they sharp or dinged?
– Edges: Whitening = bad
– Surface: Scratches or scuffs? Print lines?
– Centering: Are borders even?
If it looks mint, you may want to grade it. If it looks like it’s been through a dryer, it’s still cool—but not valuable.
Step 6: Popularity Matters (Sorry, Dunsparce)
Not all Pokémon are created equal in collector value. High-demand characters include:
– Charizard
– Pikachu
– Blastoise
– Venusaur
– Gengar
– Mewtwo
– Mew – (Here’s our Mew Black Star Promo)
– Eeveelutions (Umbreon, Espeon, etc.)
Even if you’ve got a rare card, if it features a forgettable Pokémon like Lickitung or Parasect, the ceiling is much lower.
Step 7: Skip the Trainer Cards (Usually)
Unless it’s a rare promo or something ultra-specific (like Tropical Wind), most Trainer cards—even rare ones—are not valuable. Same goes for Energy cards. Nobody’s paying $100 for a 1999 Grass Energy.
Step 8: Promo Cards Can Be Wild Cards
Got a card with a “Promo” stamp? Check the history. Some promos, like the Ancient Mew or Pokémon Movie cards, are mass-produced but still nostalgic. Others, like championship promos or certain Japanese exclusives, can actually be worth something—especially graded.
Step 9: Japanese Cards – Not Always Less Valuable
Japanese Base Set holos and promos are often in better condition and sometimes more valuable due to lower population reports. Don’t dismiss them just because they’re not in English—just make sure you research the specific card.
Step 10: Use Sold Listings, Not Guesswork
Search your card on eBay and **filter to “Sold Listings.”** That’s what people are actually paying—not what sellers are hoping for.
Compare:
– Raw card price
– PSA 8–10 slab prices
– Shadowless vs Unlimited vs 1st Edition
Even commons can surprise you if they’re pristine and low-pop.
Bonus: What’s Definitely Binder Filler?
Let’s be honest. Some stuff isn’t even worth sleeving.
– Damaged commons/uncommons
– Base Set 2 or Legendary Collection non-holos
– Non-holo rares from late WOTC sets
– Played-out Energies and Trainers
– “Cool” Pokémon that aren’t actually rare
That doesn’t mean throw them away. It means don’t spend an hour listing them individually for $0.75. Sell as a bulk lot—or keep for nostalgia.
Final Take
Your childhood collection might not make you rich—but it’s not worthless either. Base Set, Shadowless, First Edition, and clean holos can still command real value. Binder filler? That’s part of the hobby too.
Think of it this way: even if your cards aren’t grails, they’re still a piece of history. Just maybe don’t expect them to pay for a Tesla.
And if you’re on the fence about grading, or you’ve got a box of maybe-maybe-not cards—stay tuned. More breakdowns are coming that show exactly when to grade, when to flip raw, and when to just enjoy the art.
0 Comments