When it comes to basketball cards, Prizm has been the hobby’s golden child for a while now. The name alone makes flippers perk up and collectors start sorting top loaders. It’s the flagship. The standard. The “if you’re only buying one rookie card, make it this” product.
But lately? Optic’s been giving it side-eye. And Select? Well… Select took its jersey off and ran into a Walmart, so we’ll get to that too.
If you’re trying to figure out where to put your basketball money—whether you’re collecting, flipping, or just trying to buy smart—this post will break it all down. Prizm is still king… but Optic might just be running for mayor.
The Prizm Pedigree
Let’s get this out of the way: Panini Prizm is still the flagship for NBA rookies. Since 2012, it’s held the crown as the go-to chromium rookie card. Silver Prizms? Iconic. Gold /10s? Grail-level. Black 1/1s? Literal hobby dreams.
Why? Because everyone agrees it matters.
It’s the card ESPN shows when a rookie explodes. It’s the card auction houses post when they break sales records. It’s the card even casual collectors know by name.
For better or worse, Prizm is still the baseline by which all other modern basketball rookies are judged.
But Here’s the Thing: Optic Is Climbing
While Prizm sits on the throne, Optic has been stacking ballots. The quality? Cleaner. The images? Sharper. The centering? Usually (not always) better. I mean, it’s still Panini, remember? QC? LOL.
And unlike Prizm, which sometimes looks like it was printed on a pizza box, Optic holos often pop better in-hand.
Optic also has Rated Rookie branding—an instant nostalgia boost tied back to the Donruss line. And as grading populations grow, savvy collectors are noticing that Optic silvers (aka holos) are often lower pop than Prizm silvers for the same player.
Which brings us to the real question: are we witnessing a shift?
The Numbers Don’t Lie (And Neither Do the Pop Reports)
Let’s take 2020 LaMelo Ball as an example:
– PSA 10 Prizm Silver: ~3,800
– PSA 10 Optic Holo: ~1,500
That’s a MASSIVE difference in supply. And while the Prizm still outsells the Optic, that gap isn’t what it used to be. More collectors are prioritizing aesthetics, scarcity, and clean surfaces—and Optic delivers on all three.
What Happened to Select?
Once upon a time, Select was the underrated darling of the hobby. It had cool courtside tiers, lower print runs, and felt more “premium” than Prizm. Then… retail happened.
Panini took Select, a once hobby-only product, and threw it on every Target shelf from California to Maine. Print runs exploded. Courtside parallels became as common as base cards. And just like that, Select’s mystique evaporated.
Today, most savvy buyers look at Select with caution. There are still some bangers—courtside golds, zebra SSPs—but the brand took a massive L in the eyes of long-term collectors.
So Where Should New Buyers Focus?
If you’re new to basketball cards (or returning post-2021), here’s the TL;DR:
– Prizm Silver: Still the blue-chip rookie card. But comps have softened, and grading pop is sky-high.
– Optic Holo: Rising fast. Cleaner, rarer, and generally cheaper. Smart value play.
– Optic Blue Velocity / Purple / Checkerboard: Look incredible. Sell well. Underappreciated still.
– Select Courtside Parallels: Only hobby versions matter. Retail? Hard pass.
If you’re trying to flip in the $5–$50 range, Optic is your friend. Holos of fringe rookies still move. And numbered parallels? Way more affordable entry point than Prizm equivalents.
Let’s Talk Parallels
This is where Prizm still flexes. The rainbow is legendary:
– Silver
– Red /299
– Blue Ice /99
– Purple Pulsar /35
– Gold /10
– Black 1/1
But it’s also bloated. Try chasing every parallel in a modern Prizm release and you’ll lose your sanity before your wallet.
Optic’s rainbows are tighter. Less fluff, more punch. And collectors love their velocity patterns. Some of the most visually underrated cards in the game, period.
Grading Trends: Which Ones Actually Gem?
This is where Optic might surprise you. On average, Optic cards grade better than Prizm. Less surface gunk. Fewer dimples. Better centering.
Why does that matter? Because grading fees aren’t cheap. If you’re sending in raw cards and hoping for 10s, Optic offers better ROI odds. And in 2024, where grading is a calculated move—not just “send it and pray”—that edge matters.
Also: Prizm centering in recent years has been borderline criminal. If you’re buying raw, bring a ruler and a therapist.
Long-Term Outlook
Prizm isn’t going anywhere. It will remain the gold standard—especially for iconic rookie years (Giannis, Luka, Zion, etc). But the throne is getting wobblier. And Optic? It’s climbing without the hobby fully realizing it.
Here’s how it could shake out:
– Prizm = King, but bloated
– Optic = Leaner, smarter, growing loyalist base
– Select = Retail casualty
– Mosaic = Fun for kids, but not a serious contender
If Fanatics plays this smart post-Panini, we might even see a reset on what “flagship chromium” means. But for now? Watch Optic. Closely.
And don’t sleep on its parallels—they might be the last bastion of underpriced greatness left in modern basketball wax.
0 Comments